The Career Engine Book a discovery call

Insights

Are you really a 90% fit? Why senior leaders misread job specs

By Caroline Warwick

You see a senior role advertised. One line in the job spec could have been written about you. You skim the rest, feel a jolt of recognition and apply that evening. Then you hear nothing.

This may sound basic, but after 25 years plus in executive search it remains one of the most common reasons senior applications fail. Even experienced leaders misread the job spec.

The one-line trap

Highly analytical leaders are especially prone to this. They find one requirement they match completely, give it far more weight than the rest and conclude that they are a strong fit. Yet if the spec lists ten requirements and you can evidence only one, you are a 10% fit, not a 90% fit. The hiring manager reads all ten.

“If the spec lists ten requirements and you can evidence only one, you are a 10% fit, not a 90% fit.”

Not every requirement is equal

A job spec has its own language. Some requirements are prerequisites: without them you will not be shortlisted, however strong the rest of your background. Others are nice-to-haves. A candidate with every nice-to-have and none of the prerequisites will rarely make the grade, yet that is exactly the application many senior leaders send.

How I work through a job spec with you

I go through each job spec with you, requirement by requirement, and ask a simple question: where is your experience for this?

Sometimes the experience is there but missing from your CV. That we can fix. Sometimes it genuinely is not there. Then that role is not the best use of your time and knowing that early saves you weeks of waiting and a good deal of unnecessary disappointment.

Fewer applications, better results

The result is fewer, better-targeted applications and a CV that answers the questions a hiring manager is actually asking. Rather than spreading your effort across roles that were never quite right, you concentrate it where your background genuinely fits.

Key takeaway

One perfect match is not a strong fit. Read the job spec the way a hiring manager does, all of it, before you decide to apply.

Back to all insights

Next step

Let’s map out your next move.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call and tell me how I can help.

Book your discovery call Brockenhurst, The New Forest, Hampshire · consultations by video or in person