The Career Engine Book a discovery call

The future of work

Gartner’s Future of Work: why critical thinking still wins the day

By Caroline Warwick

Gartner recently presented its 2025 Future of Work webinar, which reported on the World Economic Forum’s view of the skills that matter most for employability in the coming years.

Here they are, in reverse order. Notice which skill comes out on top.

  • #6  How to write prompts
  • #5  Discernment: how to verify information provided by AI
  • #4  Tech fluency
  • #3  Machine learning
  • #2  Big data modelling
  • #1  Critical thinking

Sources: Gartner, The Future of Work; World Economic Forum.

Why critical thinking matters even more in the age of AI

At first glance, it seems counterintuitive. Large language models can now draft a strategy paper, summarise a 200-page report or answer almost any question in seconds. Surely that makes human thinking less valuable, not more?

The opposite is true. When answers are instant and free, the scarce skill is no longer finding an answer. It is knowing whether the answer is right, whether it was the right question in the first place and what to do next.

AI is confident, not always correct

An LLM will give you a fluent, persuasive answer whether it is right or wrong. It can present out-of-date information, invent a source or miss the context that matters most to your business. The more polished the output, the easier it is to accept without question. That is why discernment sits at number five on the list. Critical thinking is what stops a well-written mistake from becoming a costly decision.

“AI can give you an answer in seconds. Knowing whether it is the right answer is still a human skill.”

Everyone now has the same tools

When every leader has access to the same AI tools, the tools themselves are no longer an advantage. What sets one leader apart from another is judgement: the ability to weigh evidence, challenge assumptions, spot what is missing and make a sound decision under pressure. That is precisely what Boards and CEOs look for when they make a senior hire.

How it shows up when you are being hired

Hiring managers are increasingly alert to answers that sound polished but have little depth behind them. A strong senior candidate can explain not just what they decided, but how they reached that decision, what they considered and rejected and what they would do differently next time. That is critical thinking in action and it is very hard to fake in a well-run interview.

The same applies to your CV. AI can help with the wording, but it cannot decide which of your achievements matter most for a particular role or how to present them to a particular hiring manager. That takes judgement. I have written more on this in Should I use AI to help me write my CV?

Keeping your thinking sharp

Use AI as a starting point, not a final answer. Ask it to challenge your thinking, not just to confirm it. Check the facts that matter before you rely on them. And make sure that the final judgement, and the final word, is always yours.

Key takeaway

In the age of instant answers, the leaders who stand out are the ones who question them.

Back to all insights

Next step

Let’s map out your next move.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call and tell me how I can help.

Book your discovery call Brockenhurst, The New Forest, Hampshire · consultations by video or in person