The Career Engine Book a discovery call

Insights

In a cautious market, transferable skills don’t transfer

Why Boards only hire the 100% match in quieter economic times

By Caroline Warwick

As a headhunter, I approach senior leaders about roles every week. When the timing is not right for them, they are often kind enough to suggest someone else. “It’s not the right time for me, but why don’t you speak to my former colleague? She would be brilliant.”

I look at the LinkedIn profile and, more often than not, I cannot quite see why that person has been put forward. Sometimes it is simply because they are actively looking. But quite often it is because the person making the referral does not see a change of sector as a big deal.

“How long can it take to learn a new vertical?”

The thinking goes like this: they are really, really good in retail, so I am sure they will be great in manufacturing. After all, how long does it take to learn a new vertical?

I understand the logic. In buoyant times, when there is a real shortage of senior talent, it often holds true. Employers will happily take a strong leader from an adjacent sector and give them time to learn.

But that is not the market we are in today.

When there is more talent than there are jobs

When there are more senior candidates than senior roles, hiring managers become very, very fussy. At this level the hiring manager is usually the CEO or even the Board and they want a candidate with zero risk attached to their profile.

By zero risk, I mean someone who has already done that exact job before. No stretch. No learning curve. No margin for error.

“In a cautious market, the Board is not hiring potential. It is hiring proof.”

Same sector, same role, same stage of growth

And exact really does mean exact: the same industry, the same vertical and the same point on the growth curve. Has this person grown a business from 100 million to 250 million before? Or from 250 million to 750 million?

This is where many strong candidates push back. “Yes, but I grew a business from 50 million to 100 million. That is much harder.” Or, “I grew a business from 1 billion to 3 billion. Those numbers are bigger, so surely that is more impressive.”

Both may well be true. Neither is the point. Each stage of growth brings its own challenges, its own systems and its own kind of team. The Board wants to know that you have solved their particular problem before, not a harder one or a bigger one.

Why caution wins right now

The cost of a wrong hire at senior level is enormous: the search itself, the package, the months lost and the damage to the business and the team if it goes wrong. When the economy is flying, a business can absorb that risk. When it is not, there is simply no room for manoeuvre.

We are in a K-shaped market. AI is growing while much of the rest of the economy is in the doldrums and even AI has seen sharp corrections. All of this breeds caution. In my view, more senior hiring mandates may yet be put on hold or cancelled, at least until early 2027.

Where there is caution, there is only tolerance for a 100% match.

What this means for you

If you are planning a move across sectors, it is not impossible. But it does mean being realistic about where you are most likely to succeed and putting your effort there first.

Look hard at your own profile the way a Board would. Where are you a 100% match: same sector, same type of role, same stage of growth? Those are the roles to prioritise now. A change of sector needs a more deliberate approach and it may be easier to achieve when the market picks up. If you do decide to make that switch, my guide on how to use LinkedIn when switching industries in the UK is a good place to start.

And if you are the one making the referral, it is worth asking the same question before you pass on a name.

This is exactly the kind of judgement I help senior leaders make: which roles are genuinely worth their time and how to position their CV for the roles where they are the strongest fit. It goes hand in hand with reading the job spec properly.

Key takeaway

In a cautious market, Boards hire proof, not potential. Target the roles where you have already done the job.

Back to all insights

Next step

Let’s map out your next move.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call and tell me how I can help.

Book your discovery call Brockenhurst, The New Forest, Hampshire · consultations by video or in person